‹ All techniques

Expert technique

Test a Bubble: Trial and Error Without Blind Guessing

Also called trial and error, bifurcation, or proof by contradiction. In Bubble Sudoku it is called Test a Bubble.

When nothing else works, you can still make progress without guessing. Pick a cell with two colors left, try one of them, and follow what it forces. If the board breaks, the other color is proved.
!Before you try this
Turn off Auto Check Mistakes in Settings before you try this on a real board. A test bubble is meant to be wrong, and with that setting on, the game flags a wrong bubble the moment it lands and costs you a life.
1

When nothing else works

BEFORE

No cell on this board shows a single color, no color has just one place left, and no pair, triple, or line pattern places anything. That is exactly when this technique works best. Eight cells here show just two colors, and the shaded one holds Red and Light Purple.

2

Try one of the two

Put a Red in that cell, just to see. This is not a guess, because we are not going to keep it. We are going to follow what it forces and watch whether the board breaks, and either answer is useful.

3

Follow what it forces

Placing the test Red removes Red from every cell it can see, and one of those is in the same block, just below and to the right. That cell only ever held Red and Light Purple, so with Red gone it has to be Light Purple. Nothing was chosen there. It was forced.

4

And what that forces

Now the same thing happens along the row. The forced Light Purple removes Light Purple from the cells it can see, including one further along its own row that also held only Red and Light Purple. So that one becomes Red. Two moves in, and we have not made a single choice.

5

The board breaks

Look at the second row from the top, shaded dark. Only two of its cells could ever have held a Red, and the two lighter columns show what happened to them: the test bubble used up one, and the Red it forced used up the other. Every row must hold a Red somewhere. This one now has nowhere to put it, which cannot happen on a real board.

6

Place the proved color

AFTER

Red led straight to an impossible board, so Red was never an option in that cell. Take the three test bubbles back off and place Light Purple instead. Nothing here was guessed. It was proved, and a proof holds no matter how long the chain took to find it.

Key cellColor tints match the color being followed

Key Insight

A guess keeps the bubble and hopes. A test keeps only what it proves, and it is worth the trouble because it always tells you something: either the board breaks and you have proved the other color, or it does not and you have learned nothing but lost nothing. Pick a cell with two colors, and pick one where the cells around it also show two, because that is where the chain moves fastest. If the chain runs longer than three or four moves without breaking, back it out and try the other color instead.

Tips and Tricks

Test the color you think is wrong. A chain that breaks proves something; a chain that runs on forever proves nothing.
Cells holding the same two colors as your test cell are where the chain will go next, so look there first.
Keep the chain short. If you cannot hold the moves in your head, you will not trust the answer at the end of it.
The in-game hint runs this whole demonstration for you when the board reaches a point where nothing simpler works.

If you’re stuck on a puzzle, see what to try next, in order.

Bubble Sudoku’s hints walk you through Test a Bubble on a real board, one step at a time.

Play free in your browser